All the Brothers Were Valiant

Audience Reviews

View More

Mark B @MarkMSW Mar 24, 2026 I think it would be appreciated by a young male who is not inundated with anime or Transformers or current Marvel, etc, superhero movies — and TCM fans. The first half is exciting and cool during the adventure on the ship. I turned it off halfway through the movie. Never really cared for Robert Taylor or Stuart Granger, Granger in Rope, yes but that’s it. To me they’re both obviously acting even though everybody else says they were good in this movie. But then it turned absurd. On the ship, Robert Taylor doesn’t sufficiently articulate a critical decision and then does some dumb ass things. But I kept watching until, in response to Taylor, Granger behaved nonsensical to his role. The best part is the adventures on old ship. The worst part was the overlooked, era-dehumanizing scenes. See more Steve D @RT35616104 Dec 25, 2023 Melodramatic eye roll worthy schlock. See more Mar 8, 2020 Melodrama on the high seas. Not great but a little interesting for 90 minute somewhat dated movie. See more Apr 7, 2019 MGM lays another egg and spends fistfuls of money on this dud. Almost everything about this film is wrong, so where do you start? MGM had a stable of stars it could have called on (some in this film) to perform in fresh, new comedies, dramas, or musicals, but it went back to a 1923 property it owned and tried to make a technicolor extravaganza about whaling and mutiny on the sea that makes no sense. None of the characters have any development and we feel nothing for any of them. There is no real tension in the air. A contented crew would not turn, en masse, on their captain if they were being well treated. What we genuinely feel is horror when one of the brothers cold-heartedly spears the natives and kills them for no good reason. This was considered to be OK back in 1953. You could kill or maim anyone who was not white -- because they were not people. Yet our sympathy stays with the natives throughout this movie and we are aghast at how the white people treat them. Times may have changed, but were our fathers and grandfathers so barbaric? It is part of our heritage, but this movie, in all respects, stinks. The "native girl" who kisses one of the crew could not, in fact, be native, she had to be white, and made up for the part. In this film, no one is valiant -- especially the writers and producers who concocted this behemoth of a monstrosity and tried to sell it to a unsuspecting public. By this time, we're very tired of seeing the same MGM clothing, scarves, and other decorations being used again in another film. The so-called glitz is so very noticeable now that you are asking yourself what sound stage did they do this scene on? and what islet of the ocean in California was this filmed? Valiant rates low in any rating system. See more Dec 15, 2018 Glossy MGM sea adventure lacks emotion. See more ashley h @ashleyhobgood87 Oct 24, 2018 All the Brothers Were Valiant is a disappointing film. It is about two brothers who fight over the same girl and over a bag of pearls. Robert Taylor and Stewart Granger give terrible performances. The screenplay is badly written. Richard Thorpe did a horrible job directing this movie. I was not impressed with this motion picture. See more Read all reviews

All the Brothers Were Valiant

My Rating

Read More Read Less WRITE A REVIEW EDIT REVIEW POST RATING